Pages

July 10, 2009

Obamacare for Everybody


Parkinson's sufferers face 'appalling gaps' in care

Parkinson's sufferers face delays in diagnosis and struggle to access specialty treatment because of failures in the NHS, a new report warns.

Kate Devlin, Medical Correspondent for The Telegraph provides us with a preview of Single-Payer Socialized Medicine.
Jim Henry, 66, a Parkinson's patient, told the inquiry: "I had to wait six months to see a specialist for my initial diagnosis, but received no information about Parkinson's at that or any subsequent appointment.
"At once stage, my neurologist went on sick leave for more than a year, with no notification or replacement service."
The All Party Parliamentary Group (APPG) for Parkinson's Disease found a postcode lottery in services across Britain and said there were too few specialist nurses to treat the estimated 120,000 sufferers in Britain.

They also warned that health professionals, including GPs, had a "poor understanding" of the disease.

Diagnosis was delayed or initially missed in up to half of patients, the inquiry heard.
Ministers and NHS managers are to blame for "appalling gaps" in services and a "lack of leadership of neurological services at national and local level" the report found.
It warns that there are too few nurse specialists to treat patients, particularly in Wales and Northern Ireland. (More...)
____________________________________________
____________________________________________


Of NICE and Men
NICE has limited the use of Alzheimer's drugs, including Aricept, for patients in the early stages of the disease.
In March, NICE ruled against the use of two drugs, Lapatinib and Sutent, that prolong the life of those with certain forms of breast and stomach cancer.
Other NICE rulings include the rejection of Kineret, a drug for rheumatoid arthritis; Avonex, which reduces the relapse rate in patients with multiple sclerosis; and lenalidomide, which fights multiple myeloma.
Speaking to the American Medical Association last month, President Obama waxed enthusiastic about countries that "spend less" than the U.S. on health care. He's right that many countries do, but what he doesn't want to explain is how they ration care to do it.

Take the United Kingdom, which is often praised for spending as little as half as much per capita on health care as the U.S. Credit for this cost containment goes in large part to the National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence, or NICE. Americans should understand how NICE works because under ObamaCare it will eventually be coming to a hospital near you.

President Barack Obama speaks about health care during a town hall meeting at Northern Virginia Community College last Wednesday.

The British officials who established NICE in the late 1990s pitched it as a body that would ensure that the government-run National Health System used "best practices" in medicine. As the Guardian reported in 1998: "Health ministers are setting up [NICE], designed to ensure that every treatment, operation, or medicine used is the proven best. It will root out under-performing doctors and useless treatments, spreading best practices everywhere."

What NICE has become in practice is a rationing board. As health costs have exploded in Britain as in most developed countries, NICE has become the heavy that reduces spending by limiting the treatments that 61 million citizens are allowed to receive through the NHS. For example:

In March, NICE ruled against the use of two drugs, Lapatinib and Sutent, that prolong the life of those with certain forms of breast and stomach cancer. This followed on a 2008 ruling against drugs -- including Sutent, which costs about $50,000 -- that would help terminally ill kidney-cancer patients. After last year's ruling, Peter Littlejohns, NICE's clinical and public health director, noted that "there is a limited pot of money," that the drugs were of "marginal benefit at quite often an extreme cost," and the money might be better spent elsewhere. (More...)



16 comments:

Anonymous said...

Good job... well said, I like your style.
But then again you're a Goomba, so I shouldn't expect anything less.

Rhod said...

The causes of Parkinson's and related conditions are well known, but numerous and intractable.

Having symptoms (dystonia), I went from my GP to a neurologist in less a week, and have been back three times in three months. I had an MRI within a week of seeing the neurologist. Great service.

A final diagnosis is difficult, but medications which sustain or generate dopamine in the brain are varied and relatively inexpensive. You can try them from the very first visit as part of the diagnostic protocol.

If, in the UK, the disease is poorly understood, it's the result of financial triaging. Ailments characteristic of old age just don't/won't get funded, and in the case of Parkinson's, medical neglect will cost more than treatment. Parkinson's kills you pretty slowly.

Anonymous said...

Thanks, NYG...

Youse is always welcome here.

Anonymous said...

Rhod,

I posted this with you in mind. And you, of course, can well imagine the effects of rationing health care.

Rhod said...

Thank you, my friend. This issue also brings up the immense burden of the old on the young and younger.

The retirement cohort is already extorting the cost of eternal youth and endless repairs from the young. AARP is a subversive organization.

I still believe that when you're number is up, you go, which is simply not the philosophy of my generation.

Since we, as a group, have lost the moral vitality to accept the inevitable, the administrative state will have to do it. One ethical failing seems to breed even more.

Opus #6 said...

This is not the America I anticipated growing old in. I sure hope this doesn't go through.

Anonymous said...

Rhod,

We're American TV watchers so we ain't exiting our own show without a happy ending.

...and a theme song.

...and now, a sponsor.

Anonymous said...

Ope...

This legislation may not be a sure thing, but infirmity and death are pretty good bets.

Rhod said...

Goomba, as you know, TV isn't the cause of American vacuity, it's the effect.

Funeral theme song? Either "Run Through the Jungle" or "Shuffle Your Feet" (BRMC).

USA_Admiral said...

This is not the America I thought I would be leaving my daughter in.

Like Opus #6 said or growing old in.

It keeps me wide awake at night.

Anonymous said...

Commodore,

I sleep with the prayer that tomorrow will be the first day of America's return to sanity.

Anonymous said...

Rhod,

My tune's gonna be Happy Trails To You.

Rhod said...

Roy Rogers. Feh!

I was an Autrey/Buttram fan. I met them in 1949.

So I guess "Here Comes Peter Cotton Tail" is my send-off tune.

Anonymous said...

Rhod,

Autry/Buttram were "Back in the Saddle Again".

I met Buttram at a friend's home in 1977. Following ample liquid refreshment, he filled the evening's hours with tales of Gene Autry drinking misadventures. I'm forever a Roy Rogers fan. Cute wife, cool horse and delicious chicken.

Rhod said...

We talked about chicken a long time ago, and I thought you liked the stuff from The Pioneer Chicken Stand.

Anonymous said...

Rhod,

Your racist statements are not welcome here.